My grandmother always used the name American Potato Salad, I have no idea where it comes from - but since she comes from Hesse (Frankfurt area), it is certainly related to the occupation.
Prepare so-called pieces of salt from the potatoes, i.e. peel and cut into pieces approx. 1x1x2cm.
As befits a post-war recipe, the cooking is energy-saving, so simply poke the eggs and add them to the potato water.
Likewise, if only briefly, the tomatoes end up in the cooking water - then they are easier to peel off.
In any case, the peeled tomatoes and the cucumbers are also diced and placed in a correspondingly large salad bowl. Add about 1 1/2 glasses of salad cream and a little of the cucumber water.
Remove the eggs from the potato water, rinse. Drain the potatoes (preferably in a colander) and drain / let them cool down a little.
Peel the eggs and cut them into slices.
Put the potatoes in the bowl and mix with the contents. Be careful not to muddle everything up.
Tip: Only add the eggs at the very end, then there is a greater chance that they will stay halfway whole.